ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Paul Frank, Fractional Head of Shopper Marketing at Legendary Foods

Explore what direct-to-consumer brands need to know before they hit the retail shelf. In this episode of the Wytpod, Paul Frank, who leads shopper and retail marketing fractionally for Legendary Foods after years at Conagra and Kellogg’s and in cannabis, joins host Stephen Bland to share why success in retail is units and dollars per store per week rather than CAC and LTV, how retail media has changed the shopper marketing role, why relying on ROAS alone can starve a brand’s organic rankings, when a fractional marketing leader makes sense, and how to get listings ready for AI discovery.

“ROAS can be incredibly misleading if not used the right way.”

Paul Frank
Fractional Head of Shopper Marketing, Legendary Foods
Paul Frank
Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Hello, everyone, I’m Stephen, your host with the Wytpod. Today’s guest is Paul. Paul, feel free to introduce yourself and let our viewers know about your background.

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Nice to meet you, Stephen, and I’m happy to be here. I currently lead shopper and retail marketing, fractionally, for Legendary Foods, but I come with a fairly diverse background. I started in traditional CPG at Conagra, then spent time with Kellogg’s, and then moved into what I’d call a very interesting space, cannabis, for multiple years, before coming back to traditional big CPG. I’ve worked across a variety of functions, including sales, marketing and analytics, and I’ve spent a significant portion of my career diving deep into omnichannel shopper marketing.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

What pulled you toward those categories, and what did the big companies teach you about how retailers think that you still use today?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

My career has naturally evolved over time. Part of it was based on personal ambitions and what I wanted to learn and grow from. I started in traditional big CPG, which is a fantastic way of getting basic CPG training and understanding how big brands scale and think through long-term strategy. I worked on a variety of high-visibility categories, things like protein, breakfast, cold cereal and Pop-Tarts. I loved my time in big CPG, and I think it trains you classically in how to manage a P&L and optimize a business.
But one of the biggest things I was looking for was true ground-up brand building: starting with a product and figuring out how to scale it in a way that’s effective and resonates with shoppers. It’s a very different skill set from what you find in large CPG, where innovation tends to happen through acquisition and M&A activity. That led me into the cannabis world, during what we called the green rush. CBD was becoming a new commodity, it was showing up in retail, and major retailers like Walmart and Target were trying to figure out how to navigate the category. It was an opportunity to build a category from the ground up, and to build brands that had never existed before, when nobody knew how to build them.
Working in the startup space, specifically in cannabis, was probably the most developmentally challenging thing I’ve ever done in my career, because there was no roadmap. Nobody had done it before, so we were blazing the trail for the first time. It was an incredible experience that I’ve carried with me to other organizations.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

When a brand that grew online or in a niche moves into big-box retail, what’s the biggest mindset shift, and what separates the brand a retailer champions from the one it simply tolerates on the shelf?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

It’s one I’ve had to navigate a few times. When you’ve got a pure-play D2C business looking to expand into retail, a few areas have to be unpacked. One is what success looks like. Success for a D2C business and success for a brand within retail look very different. You no longer just have yourself as a stakeholder. You have to think about what’s important to the merchant and how you stack up against the competition, on both the digital shelf and the physical shelf. Instead of focusing on efficiency metrics like CAC and LTV, you now have to think about units per store per week and dollars per store per week, because those directly affect merchant scorecards. There’s a big mental shift in measurement, and tied to that is where investments go.
I’ve seen this with both small and large brands. Small brands moving into retail for the first time think success is getting onto the shelf, and actually that’s just when the journey begins. Now you have to figure out how to accelerate velocity in a way that’s sustainable, and which metrics you’ll focus on for your marketing investments. If you’re a new brand trying to drive trial, shifting the focus to new-to-brand acquisition and away from efficiency metrics, at least in the early development stages, becomes critical. The stage of a brand’s life plays into it too. A D2C brand that’s widely known with broad awareness takes a slightly different approach than a brand that’s only been in the D2C space for a couple of years and is still actively trying to build awareness, rapport and trust with shoppers.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Shopper marketing has moved from end caps and coupons to retail media networks and omnichannel. What has that shift improved for brands, what has quietly made it harder, and how should leaders balance retail media spend against long-term brand building? It’s a very loaded question.

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

It is a loaded question, and one I love, because there are so many components. The function has gone from being called trade marketing to retail marketing, then shopper marketing, then connected commerce. There are a variety of ways of describing it, but a lot of it has to do with the role it plays and what you’re trying to get shopper marketing to achieve. We started with print and analog, moved to digital coupons, and eventually merged into retail media, which continues to be the hot-button marketing lever.
What it has done is force organizations and brands to understand where their investment goes and what the role of shopper marketing actually is. It’s no longer just a bottom-of-funnel conversion lever. You now have to think about the full funnel and how it intersects with your brand media, and those two can’t be planned in a silo. Larger organizations have a hard time with this. I’d say established CPG companies have a harder time breaking down those silos than scaling brands, which are more flexible and nimble.
Take Walmart as an example. With Walmart’s recent acquisition of Vizio and the ability to leverage Walmart Connect’s first-party data, you have a completely different tool set. You can use that first-party data to enhance your targeting and personalization, and you have a full-funnel spread through the Walmart DSP. So the question becomes defining the role of each media investment. Instead of looking at brand media versus retail media, you have to look at the total mix to understand whether it will be most effective in driving your brand’s ultimate objectives.
Where this helps small brands and where it hurts them is that they’re never going to outspend large brands. If you’re a new disruptor in the category, it’s incredibly challenging to go up against a P&G in overall marketing spend, so you have to think shrewdly about where every dollar goes and what its objective is. A lot of that comes down to the measurement that comes with retail media networks, and understanding which networks truly show incrementality versus just vanity metrics. I could talk about vanity metrics all day. But it gives small brands an opportunity to invest at a level they historically would have been boxed out of, given the minimums many DSPs require.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

You’ve worked in industries where you can’t advertise freely, or where shoppers are naturally skeptical. What actually earns a brand credibility, and does that apply to mainstream brands too?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

It does apply to mainstream brands, and it depends on the category. I’ve worked on highly regulated categories like cannabis, but I also spent about three years on OTC hearing aids, which is a very high-consideration category. The first thing to unpack is the level of consideration the shopper needs before making a purchase decision. Are they researching the product before they decide, or is it an impulse purchase that doesn’t carry much weight or financial impact?
In fast-moving consumer goods, the burden is slightly different. Shoppers want to know whether it will meet their needs on taste, format and use case, and they quickly look at things like star ratings, flavor profiles, and how you show up on the digital shelf and on packaging. That plays a much heavier role. In higher-consideration categories like OTC hearing aids, research is taking place, and a lot of it is happening through AI channels and basic search engines. Showing up with the right level of content for the level of consideration is very important. Give them too much and you’ve lost the shopper. Don’t give them enough and your competitors show up with a more compelling value proposition.
So it goes back to understanding what the shopper is looking for and the level of information they need, and then choosing the mediums you show up in. That could be AI optimization and making sure you show up on the agentic platforms, or it could be a more analog approach. Is consideration taking place on the retailer’s site before the store, or directly in the store, depending on the category?

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

The biggest question I get is about AI, because most shoppers use an AI assistant or a search engine before they buy, even before they reach the store. How is that changing the role of the shelf, and what does it signal that a brand needs to do to be part of those answers?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Discovery and research aren’t new, and the intent is to give shoppers the right information to make the right purchase decision. We’re seeing that evolve in different ways across retail. Amazon, for example, now has AI integrated directly into its platform and shopping experience, and my guess is we’ll see that become more ubiquitous throughout the rest of retail. It depends on the individual category. Brands can now advertise across things like ChatGPT and Anthropic, but it’s a question of whether that’s required for your brand at this stage of development. If you’re an established brand trying to squeeze out additional revenue, it could make sense to delve into that.
For scaling startup brands, I’ve found that’s not where most of them focus today. They’re squarely focused on retailer.com. But making sure your listings and product information are optimized to be picked up by AI algorithms, things like star ratings, SEO and, quite frankly, AI optimization of your PDP content and listings, are critical foundational elements, so that when the brand is ready to scale within AI, it’s ready to do so.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

How do you use AI day to day in your life right now?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Nonstop, but very carefully and diligently. We’re not going to escape AI. It’s here to stay. My biggest concerns are how to contain it and use it effectively, not to replace people but to reduce administrative tasks so we can focus on strategic decisions. I use it across a variety of touchpoints. A lot of it is reporting and administrative work like deck creation, but there are much more sophisticated ways to use it, like layering in data sources from operations, sales and marketing to see where we’re seeing macro trends across the business. Things that used to take weeks to analyze, we can analyze in minutes. When we see a decline in certain retail channels, is it a result of fill-rate problems, marketing efficiency or competitor activity? It’s endless.
Again, the danger is whether the data is accurate, whether it’s been cleaned correctly and whether it’s actionable. Before you know it, you’ve ended up with 15 different dashboards that you can’t actually leverage, instead of getting the data and information focused to speed up decision making and insight mining.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

You’ve worked as a fractional head of shopper and retail marketing. When does a fractional leader create the most value for a brand, when is it the wrong model, and when should a founder look at their first retail marketing hire?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

It depends on each organization and what it’s trying to achieve. If you’re hiring a retail consultant to do fractional work, do they have the autonomy to make decisions for the organization, or are you simply looking for off-site strategic guidance? It also depends on where the brand is in its development and the foundational operating model it has in place. Do you have strong executors and you’re missing the strategic lever? Or are you starting from square one and looking for someone to show you how to build the function in the most efficient and effective way and speed up your go-to-market timing?
When an organization is looking for a fractional person to act as its permanent shopper marketer, it tends not to work, especially when the brand is in scaling or optimization mode. You need somebody fully dedicated and integrated within your brand who knows it inside and out. It’s not just about picking a tactical smorgasbord of items to execute, although it could be if that’s defined up front. Most of the time you need somebody living and breathing your shopper, who understands the core objectives of the organization and, because of the integration between brand media and retail media, knows how to bring those two together.
As for when founders should bring on that function, I recommend it’s before you launch in retail, just as you’re running through your pitches and building out your story, so you get guidance on the investments required. It’s not just about getting distribution. It’s about how to accelerate velocities. A retail marketer can give you the perspective on what it costs to do business in retail, whether you have that fat in your P&L today, and what it will take to reach the velocities required to stay on shelf and expand distribution.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

That’s amazing advice. Looking back, what’s one belief about retail marketing you’ve completely changed your mind on?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Measurement, completely. It’s probably not a popular opinion, and I don’t know if a lot of my colleagues would agree. When retail media first came about, it pulled in standard measurement metrics: ROAS, click-through rates, impressions, yada yada yada. Quite frankly, it’s not good enough, and retail media networks are going to have to keep evolving their measurement approach. ROAS is a metric I can’t stand, and all my colleagues know that about me. I think it can be incredibly misleading if not used the right way, and it only tells a very small portion of the story.
I think measurement is evolving beyond that, toward incrementality and brand recall, especially now that we have full-funnel capabilities within retail marketing. Focusing on ROAS can be very short-sighted, but changing that takes a lot of internal convincing and educating, especially of finance functions that have grown up looking through the lens of an ROI model. It also means understanding the impact on organic sales. We focus on ROAS and the immediate impact of ad investments, but I’ve seen brands struggle with the impact on organic rankings and organic sales, which are the lifeblood of any brand on the marketplace today.
Amazon has done a terrific job of marrying those two together. Your BSR, your best seller rank, is directly affected by your media investment, or at least that’s one of the components. If you simply focus on ROAS as a metric, you could starve your brand’s investment out of the gate and double the negative impact by reducing your BSR ranking, and then see a decline in overall sales far beyond the impact of your initial media investment.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

I would agree. So Paul, what does the future look like for you?

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

I love consulting, and I love what I’ve done building brands. I want to keep working with large brands that are willing to disrupt, and those are few and far between, brands truly looking to disrupt and move quickly, as well as challenger brands. I love working with an underdog, because they’ve got a lot of upside, and I go back to true brand-building work, which is where that exists. The brands being built today that are only several million or ten million dollars are going to be the future billion-dollar brands.
It brings a unique challenge, because you have to have the long-term vision of a strategic big CPG brand but also understand how to get the flywheel moving early enough to make the brand sustainable and reach the next stage of growth. So I’ll continue working with brands looking for the next evolution of their growth journey.

Podcast interviewer: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Awesome, Paul. I really appreciate your time and you coming on the Wytpod and sharing your story.

Podcast guest: ROAS Alone Can Starve a Brand, Retail Media & Shopper Marketing with Paul Frank

Likewise, Stephen. I appreciate it. Thanks so much.

Get a Proposal

Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call

    Form data

    Name*

    Email*

    Website*

    Phone*

    Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call


    Ready to think big?

      Form data

      Would you prefer to talk to someone in peron?

      SPEAK WITH A STRATEGIST