Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Randy Lewis, Founder of Dragon Skin

Explore how Dragon Skin, the first company to make stingray-resistant surfing booties, grew from a side project into a full-time brand. In this episode of the Wytpod, founder Randy Lewis joins host Stephen Bland to share how smokescreen MVPs tested demand before he quit his engineering job, why he would pursue ideas in series rather than in parallel, how to market to people who don’t know the problem exists, why earned press fades but personal customer service lasts, how to win over overseas factories and local surf shops, and how Dragon Skin is writing content for AI search.

“You pick an idea based on your intuition, but you need to test that people actually want it.”

Randy Lewis
Founder, Dragon Skin
Randy Lewis
Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Hello, and welcome to the latest Wytpod. I’m Stephen, your host. Today’s guest is Randy. Randy, feel free to introduce yourself and let our viewers know about your background.

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

My name’s Randy. I’m the founder of Dragon Skin Stingray Resistant Booties. We’re the first company in the world to make surfing booties, which are basically socks for the ocean that protect you from stingray injuries. Stingray injuries are a pretty big problem in certain areas of the world, like Southern California, where we’re based, and also Florida and some other tropical areas. Basically, people step on these pancake fish, and the pancake fish knife them with a venomous and terribly painful barb. So we make footwear that protects against that.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

You and your roommates had tried some ideas in the past, then a family friend suggested the stingray booties, and you recently left your engineering job to run the company full time. Take us through that whole arc. What made the idea stick when others didn’t, and how has your engineering background helped build the brand?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Soon after college I wanted to start a company, so I reached out to my two former roommates, Michael and Bulos, who I knew were interested too, because we’d talked about a lot of startup ideas in college but never acted on anything. We got together with the intention of starting a company before we knew exactly what we were going to do. We pursued a number of ideas over the years. The two other biggest were a healthy, fewer-additives trail mix brand called Nature’s Handful, and a remote tech support service called Helping Mouse, an on-demand, Uber-like way to connect people who want to give tech support with people who need it at the moment of need. Neither went anywhere.
We started Nature’s Handful because I’m a health nut and I mix my own trail mix, and Michael liked it and was giving it to his grad school friends, who liked it too. We set up a website and pretended we already had it manufactured in bulk, basically a smokescreen MVP, and drove some people to it with Google Ads. No one tried to buy it, so we wrote it off as not an intense enough problem. I’m just weird, and the things I care about are different from what other people care about. But the technique of the smokescreen MVP has been very persistent throughout our journey, in making sure that what you’re doing actually has some demand.
With Helping Mouse we got a couple of customers, some senior folks who wanted tech support, and in the beginning we were just doing the tech support ourselves, even though that wasn’t the long-term plan. We only ever got about three customers and spent a lot of time on it, so it wasn’t catching on. In retrospect, I think any platform-based economy has a huge cold-start problem, and we didn’t appreciate that. We were also doing it on the side of our full-time jobs, and people want tech support in the middle of the day, so you can’t take a support call during business hours the way you can do engineering at night. It also had a marketing problem, because the people most in need of computer help weren’t online, so they were harder to market to. But it did put us in the right mindset of trying things and seeing them work or not work.
A couple of years into that journey, one of my mom’s friends, who had grown up in La Jolla in Southern California, said, “You guys should make booties that protect people from stingrays, because people get stung all the time there and it’s horrible, and regular booties don’t protect you.” This was right around the time Michael, one of my co-founders, was getting into surfing. People were telling us all about it, and we could verify that it was a real problem. It was up our alley too, because Michael and I were mechanical engineers, and Bulos was more on the business side. We spent about a year catching stingrays, measuring them, prototyping a bunch of different materials and testing them against a stingray-replication pendulum.
Maybe it was a little too long, but we spent a year until we could buy some off-the-shelf booties, modify them by hand, and be pretty confident they would protect from stingrays. One surf instructor, who had been stung about twenty-five times, tried them for free and said, “These are pretty good,” so we felt comfortable selling them. We wanted to make sure people would buy them before pursuing it further, so we put up another smokescreen MVP, except this one could actually ship, it just required a lot of manual effort. It started ranking on Google quicker than we expected, just because no one else was talking about this problem but people were Googling it, and we got a couple of sales a week. It took two hours to modify each booty by hand, which wasn’t sustainable, and even though they protected you from injuries, they kind of fell apart because they were made by hand. We did about a dozen orders that way, then paused taking orders and decided that, since at least some people were buying, we should get them manufactured overseas.
During that time we left the website up, which got a lot of SEO over the years just from having a long history, and we had people sign up for an interest list to buy it when it was available. It ended up taking us three years to manufacture them overseas, way longer than we expected, and I don’t think we would have kept going if people hadn’t been filling out the interest list. It was one person every day or two, but that was enough to say we weren’t totally wasting our time. So you pick an idea based on your intuition, but you need to test that people actually want it or you’re wasting your time. My other advice is to pick one that’s well suited to your area of expertise. We were surfers and mechanical engineers in Southern California, the stingray capital of the world, so this was very well suited to us, whereas Helping Mouse was maybe okay but not great. And we pursued a lot of the ideas in parallel, which dispersed our efforts. If I did it again, I’d pick the most promising idea, try to get validation or invalidation as quickly as possible, and do them more in series.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

You’ve been candid that the fear of running out of money kept you part time, and in hindsight slowed the company. For founders stuck in that in-between stage, how do you think about the risk, whether to de-risk or go all in?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

That’s often the million-dollar question, and there’s no real silver bullet, but I think you can make a better decision based on some heuristics. It’s probably a good idea to validate your market before you quit your day job. We had a smokescreen MVP up and were making them by hand, and people were filling out our interest list long before we quit our day jobs. I don’t regret that. If we hadn’t, we would have quit when we were still doing Nature’s Handful, which went nowhere, and that would have been a really bad idea.
I also think you want to estimate the total addressable market of your product. If it’s smaller, that leans toward bootstrapped, organic, slower growth. If it’s bigger, you might want to raise money, because otherwise someone can crush you by having more resources. And of course you want to do a runway calculation: how much savings you have, or what you’ve raised or will raise, and how long you can survive before the company is paying for itself. Factor in that as a founder you’ll be overly optimistic about what you can accomplish and how quickly things will grow. We did that pretty badly. The best advice I have is to find similar companies that have published their early growth numbers, both revenue and profit, and keep in mind that those are heavily selected for survivorship bias, because the other ten people who started a similar company didn’t survive long enough to post their numbers. So that’s probably the upper limit of what you should expect, even though it’s the only published figure. For us, I think we’re similar to Xero Shoes, and also to Ocean Guardian, an electrical shark deterrent that actually works, as compared to some of the other products on the market that I’m suspicious of.
People also say to quit your job and try a startup when you’re young, and I think that’s super true. The older you get, the more people depend on you: maybe a romantic partner, maybe kids, maybe older parents or family members. The more people depending on you financially, the less you’re able to take a risk. If you only have to convince yourself and your co-founders that a thing that has cost you a hundred thousand dollars over three years and returned nothing financially is worth quitting for and pursuing full time, you have a much higher chance of doing it than if you also have to convince other people, and people are really depending on you to bring in money next year.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

That’s 100% true and amazing advice. Speaking of sharks, most people fear sharks, not stingrays, and assume a normal surf bootie already protects them. So your real competitor is a misconception. How do you market when you first have to convince people the problem exists, and where do you draw the line between education and marketing, like riding moments such as El Niño, and fear itself?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

I think of it in terms of expanding spheres. There’s a smaller group of people who are very aware of the stingray problem. Surf instructors in Southern California have all been stung at least five times. They’re taping seal mesh to their Converse shoes, going in the ocean and Googling it constantly. You start with the people who are easiest to convert, and they already know it’s a problem and are desperately looking for a solution.
The next sphere is people who are aware there’s a problem but don’t think there’s a solution. Maybe they’ve been stung once, or a friend has, or they know someone who was stung through a booty, so they assume all booties aren’t stingray resistant and it’s impossible to make one. Why would they even Google it? To find those people you need more interrupt-driven advertising. The first group, who are desperately searching, you find where they search, which is Amazon and Google. If you rank well on Amazon, Google Shopping and Google SEO, you do well. For the second sphere, paid social ads can be targeted by demographics, so you reach people who live in the right area and do the right activities and probably know they have the problem. We also sponsor stingray treatment bags for the lifeguards, because the treatment for a stingray injury is to soak your foot in hot water. Lifeguard agencies have limited funding, so we put our name on those bags and provide them free to the San Diego lifeguards.
The third sphere is people who aren’t even aware there’s a problem and are more afraid of sharks, even though shark attacks are super uncommon. It’s frequently compared to being struck by lightning, which I think is a pretty good comparison. There are a lot of sharks in the water, but they don’t want anything to do with people. Here it’s even more interrupt-driven media. We’ve seen paid social ads do very well with tourists. The locals in areas where stingrays are a problem usually know about it and maybe don’t know there’s a solution, so they’re in the second sphere. Tourists are more like, “What, there’s a fish that’s going to knife me underwater?” They’ve never heard of it.
Retail has also been very good for tourists. They’re already going to the surf shop for sunscreen they forgot or a surf lesson, and they see our big booty display saying stingray injuries are ten thousand times more common than shark attacks. Retail matters for a second reason too. You go to LA for a vacation for five days, and two days in someone gets stung right next to you and you realize it’s a problem. You’re not going to wait three days for a product to ship, so you have to be able to pick it up right there, or it won’t work for you.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Understood. You’ve earned TV and reasonable press, including stingray science coverage, and your reviews keep mentioning the team by name. For a young brand, what do earned media and the human experience do for credibility that paid channels can’t, and are there limits?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

I’d separate the press and the reviews. Both are useful. We found it surprisingly easy to get covered by the press in the beginning, because stingrays are a big local problem that the press writes about multiple times a summer, at least in SoCal, and everyone loves a local-entrepreneur-solves-local-problem story. But then it became very hard, and we’ve never been covered again, because now the story is that a bunch of people are getting stung by stingrays and this company, which has been at it for about seven years, is still selling the same product. They don’t really care anymore. They still write articles about stingrays, but not about us. So you have to find the overlap between what gets your message out and what makes an interesting story. The closest we’ve come recently was when a journalist was writing about El Niño and how it increases stingray injuries, and we did get mentioned, but only a little. It’s more of a story to them because El Niño only happens once every couple of years, so it’s limited in time.
On the reviews side, it really depends on your product, but we’re running a luxury-priced product that’s critical for the safety of some people in a really niche area, so it makes sense for us to have above-and-beyond customer service. We recently hired someone to run customer service, but for many years my co-founder Bulos was running it and I still heavily supervise it. Customers notice when you do that. It’s not something you can do forever, but it’s an advantage you have when you’re small. The CEO of O’Neill can’t do personal customer service because they have a million customers. But when a customer realizes you own the company, caught the stingrays, tested them and can actually answer their questions, even ones off the boilerplate, and you give them a real, down-to-earth estimate and ask how their surfing is going or how the waves are, they really like it. It’s like Paul Graham’s “do things that don’t scale,” but for customer service. You do it as long as you can.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

A hundred percent. The question I get asked daily is about AI, the opposite of human interaction. As AI assistants get asked things like whether surf booties really protect against stingrays, how do you think about being trusted in those moments, and where do you rely on AI tools these days?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

In my personal usage, or in trying to get discovered by customers through it?

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Both.

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

In personal usage, I use it a lot to modify our Shopify website. Shopify has limited customization in its GUIs and apps, so a lot of it you have to do in software. I can write a little software, and AI helps with that. As for getting recommended, it’s honestly kind of new to us, and my co-founder handles AEO, answer engine optimization, more than I do, so I don’t know how we’re doing. But over the years we’ve killed it on traditional SEO, and I think the overlap in how you optimize for the two is pretty similar, maybe with some different files, like a robots-type file for AI, something like llms.txt, though I can’t remember exactly. I’ve also heard AEO is a bit more question-and-answer, because if you write the question and then the answer, it’s less work for the AI agent to feed your answer when someone types the same question.
Overall I’d say it comes down to two things. One is that the robots are paying attention to human behavior on your site: are people staying, are they engaging, do they start and end their user journey with your site? If they purchase your product, they’re not going to keep searching. You don’t have full control over that, but the better product and site you make, the more the robots will notice the human behavior. The other is the quality of the information you publish. If you write articles about areas tangential to your problem and take real positions on the questions, like our article on whether surfing booties or water shoes protect you from stingray injuries, which is a question you mentioned earlier, then instead of doing what most blogs do, reading all the other blogs and summarizing them, you should have an actual opinion and know things that aren’t on the internet because you’ve talked to experts and done your own testing. A lot of what’s on the internet is just regurgitated BS, like “the sun revolves around the earth.”
The example in our area is that whenever anyone talks about stingray injuries, they talk about the stingray shuffle, dragging your feet through the sand rather than picking them up with each step, so you bump into the side of a stingray rather than pin it down and cause it to sting you. There’s a little evidence for this reducing your chance of being stung, but people greatly overrate their confidence in it. There’s maybe one or two studies published in the last couple of years suggesting it may reduce your chance, but everyone’s knee-jerk reaction is “stingray shuffle.” To be clear, we do still recommend it, but we also have our own takes on what might actually prevent you from getting stung, such as not touching the bottom of the ocean if you can avoid it, which will definitively help.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

You sell through physical retailers near the beach, and of course online. What challenges have you faced in the past few years, and how did you overcome them?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

The biggest challenge over the course of the company has been getting the booties manufactured overseas. It’s impractical to manufacture in the US, because labor costs are so high that US consumers aren’t willing to pay the price you’d have to charge. You also have to go where the existing manufacturing facilities and expertise for your category are, or you’ll be trying to teach a factory both how to make this kind of product and your specific product, which is way too hard. It’s also very counter to lean startup principles, because you want to get an MVP out, get feedback and iterate as quickly as possible, but the factories want to do as few samples as possible and have you place a bulk order as soon as possible, because that’s when they make money. It also takes at least six months to get something made overseas, which really reduces your iteration time.
It’s not a problem we’ve fully solved, but one thing that really helps is treating finding a factory as a long-term business partner relationship. It’s not enough to tell them you’re going to sell it. You almost have to signal that you actually can sell it, because it’s not worth their time unless you can sell a lot of them, so you want to prove your commitment that you’ll still be around. In the beginning, our manufacturer was apparently not very impressed with us, because they thought we were a bunch of young kids, like college students, who thought they could do a thing. Then at some point we gave them a thirty-five-page manufacturing specifications document that took us a really long time to write. They told us years later that they’re not even sure they read the whole thing, but when they saw it was thirty-five pages, they thought, these guys are serious about quality, and because they’re serious about quality, they’ll stay around. So they put more effort into prioritizing our samples. I also don’t think we haggle on price as much as many other brands do. Not that we’d buy at any price, but you have to make sure your business partners are making a profit as well as you are.
That’s true in retail too, which you asked about. One of the recent challenges has been getting more into retail, because surf and water sports shops and kiteboarding schools are really good for discoverability, and they all have very good local influence. But it was really hard to get into those shops at first, I think primarily because the owners, like every small business owner, are juggling a million things. It’s not that they weren’t interested. They’re interested in a thousand things and only have time to do ten. We found going in person very effective, because they often don’t answer email, or answer it once every three months, and you’re a lot harder to ignore in person. Again, it’s doing things that don’t scale. The first couple of shops we sold were just me being in the shop whenever the owner was willing to meet, giving them free product, demoing it with their instructors, who are highly motivated, and convincing them to give it a shot. After that it’s how well it actually sells, so I did things that don’t scale again, putting in a lot of effort to make sure the shop employees knew about the product and there were good display materials so it could be discovered. We did that for our first three shops, but then you run out of time and have to back off and do it in a more scalable way. By then you have references, because one shop will buy it since it sold well in another. It’s still early days. I think we’re in about twelve shops right now, but I want to be in a hundred or two hundred.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Definitely. So Randy, what does the future look like for you and the brand, Dragon Skin?

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Right now the biggest effort is expanding to adjacent products, which we’ve tried before but not very successfully. In the past we thought, we already make stingray-resistant booties, so what’s something else people want in the ocean? We ended up making a waterproof surf hat, but it didn’t really resonate. One of our customers wrote something like, “It’s hard to tell this is even made by the same brand. I thought you guys made transformative, one-of-a-kind products, and this is just a waterproof hat.” That was hard to read, but it was also good advice. So we’re going back to the drawing board and asking what one-of-a-kind, transformative products we can make that are close enough to our area of expertise that we don’t have to start from the ground up.
The main two things are, first, a stingray go-bag, a pain relief kit that uses chemical heating packs to heat water on the go, so you can soak your stingray injury in hot water if you’re at a beach that doesn’t have hot water from the lifeguards or doesn’t have electricity. That’s in beta right now, and we released it a couple of months ago. Second, we’ve noticed over the years that a lot of people use our booties for slightly different purposes than we designed them for, other sports like kiteboarding, which is a big one. Honestly, our booties just don’t hold up well for kiteboarding. Kiteboards have foot straps on top that put pressure where there isn’t any in surfing, and it’s causing durability issues. So we’re making different variants of the booties designed for different activities, like tourists, water sports instructors, wade fishermen in Texas, and people doing wind sports like kiteboarding, winging and windsurfing, which are big in Florida.

Podcast interviewer: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

Definitely. That’s where I’m based. Randy, I appreciate you coming on the Wytpod and sharing your story and your brand. We really appreciate it.

Podcast guest: Test Before You Quit, Marketing an Unknown Problem & Retail with Randy Lewis

It was fun. I like talking about it. Thanks for having me.

Get a Proposal

Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call

    Form data

    Name*

    Email*

    Website*

    Phone*

    Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call


    Ready to think big?

      Form data

      Would you prefer to talk to someone in peron?

      SPEAK WITH A STRATEGIST