Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Todd Steinberg, Owner of Plush in a Rush

Explore how Plush in a Rush, a Dallas-based wholesale designer and distributor of plush toys and teddy bears, has stayed a trusted supplier for 35 years. In this episode of the Wytpod, owner Todd Steinberg joins host Stephen Bland to share how a family business that started with a duffel bag of samples moved online in 2003, why the company calls itself America’s Plush Headquarters, how teddy bears ended up as props on The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, what joining the Fair marketplace has brought, why he uses AI like a power tool rather than a CEO, and why the blog makes customers the hero.

“When you pick up the phone, you’ll actually talk to a real person, not a recording, not an AI bot.”

Todd Steinberg
Owner, Plush in a Rush
Todd Steinberg
Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Hello, everyone, and welcome to our latest Wytpod. I’m Stephen, your host. Today’s guest is Todd. Todd, feel free to introduce yourself and let our viewers know about your background.

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Sure. My name is Todd Steinberg, originally from Dallas, Texas, where my business is. I’ve recently moved the family to Castle Rock, Colorado, and I’m working remotely. I’m the owner of a 35-year-old plush business. We’re wholesale designers and distributors of plush toys, teddy bears and the like. I’m looking forward to this next chapter, now that I’m the sole owner. It’s been a fun ride, and I love what I do.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

How did you get into the teddy bear business?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

It was my dad and uncle’s business. When I joined in 2003, this was before the internet had become a huge thing, and especially before e-commerce. We were mostly driving from town to town with a duffel bag full of stuffed animal samples, writing up orders on sheets of paper and faxing them to the office where they’d be fulfilled. Within the first year I had built a website. Of course, anyone can build a website, even back in 2003, but getting attention to it is another thing, and getting qualified traffic is another. Slowly over time I was able to do that too, until eventually we really didn’t have to go out and meet our customers. It made more sense to stay at the office and work that angle rather than go door to door.
We still try to keep a high-touch feel with our customers. We send them physical things, not only with each package but also in the mail. It’s not a software-as-a-service type thing where there’s no tangible product. Because we’re shipping teddy bears, it’s something you touch and feel, so we keep that alive in everything we do.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Rainn Wilson once introduced you on his podcast as his friend who runs a teddy bear company. What did you inherit from the family, and did your early time around SoulPancake change the way you think about content and audience?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

I met Rainn through his dad. I actually met his dad while on a pilgrimage in Haifa, Israel. That’s a long story, so I’ll cut to the chase. He introduced me to Rainn, and I flew out to visit the set of the office. That’s when he invited me to be part of SoulPancake, which was a site about spirituality and such. I handled their Twitter feed and wrote a few articles. It was a completely different audience from the one we’re going after, so I can’t say I learned any direct lessons from my time there, but it did help me develop a good relationship with Rainn. He continues to help me, I continue to help him, and it’s a great friendship.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

You’ve called the company America’s Plush Headquarters, and your journey went from door-to-door samples and Texas trade shows to moving online in 2003. How did that identity take shape, and what has remained important to you when it comes to building trust with buyers over the years?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Back in 2018 we hired a marketing consultant who’s still with us. He asked us whether we wanted to be the number one plush company in the world, or in America, or just have a nice small business. We didn’t quite have the answer. My uncle and I were basically partners at the time, since my dad had passed a few years before. We said we like what we’re doing in the sense that we get to go home at five, not work weekends, and have a life. So if we grow, we want to grow organically and smoothly. We don’t want to invest in a bigger warehouse or hire a huge team of middle managers.
Through this consultant we surveyed our customers to see how they felt about us, and we do that periodically. One thing they weren’t sure about was whether we were some mom-and-pop place selling stuffed animals out of a garage or a major corporation. It was all over the map. When you’re on a website, you can be anyone. So we decided to lean into that and call ourselves America’s Plush Headquarters, and it’s really helped. Even though the majority of our products come from overseas, we’re based out of Dallas, Texas, we ship same or next business day, and people know that when you pick up the phone you’ll actually talk to a real person, not a recording and not an AI bot. That’s pretty much how we identify ourselves.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

Your bears have turned up as props on The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, been mentioned in reviews, and the company has been featured on NBC’s Today Show. Are moments like that luck, or can a brand put itself in front of those opportunities? And what does that do for your credibility?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

I wish I could say I knew someone in Hollywood and demanded that they write teddy bears into the script. Rainn turned me on to the creators of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, but really we had customers who bought our plush to use as props for the background, maybe for carnivals or children’s rooms. Then one day we got a request, not from the prop master but from a VP, and they wanted not just a dozen or two teddy bears but hundreds of one particular color. We were pleased as punch that this was going to be a major plot point in one of their episodes, and I think it showed up in two or three episodes.
As for NBC and all those things, it was just our customers. They were nonprofits, and the nonprofit got featured, so they indirectly put us on. I did call up the hotel that had the yellow bears, because I thought, hey, we’re the guys with the yellow bears, we could put them in your gift shop. They said no, they were out of there. They said they were going to fix the hotel back to the way it was, but they kept it in this 1950s motif. So, no thanks, they were done with it, and that was that.
What we’ve done since then is hire a film crew to film some of our customers, put the spotlight on them, put that on our website and share it with our email list. It shows that we’re not just guys stuffing bears in a box who don’t care what happens. We want to know how our end users use our toys, so we follow them all the way to the end, where they did really cool things with them.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

For a wholesale brand, being found online, and being discovered by a florist or a shop owner like a hotel, has changed over the last few years. How do you balance your own website against marketplaces like Fair, where buyers already browse?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

We recently did join Fair. We’d known about them for years, but at the time they seemed to be a small startup, and we did a better job of attracting customers than Fair did. They also didn’t seem to have any syncing tools, so you’d have to keep one inventory with Fair and one with Shopify. But they got through those obstacles, so I thought, okay, let’s give it a shot. Also, if you already had a customer and they bought through Fair, you wouldn’t have to pay the commission. We’ve been with them just a month, and we’ve gotten about 40 new customers from them. Of course, in the wholesale business it’s not the first order, it’s the second and the third, so it’s the lifetime value.
But generally speaking, we really rely on SEO. Because we started back in 2003 and put up a website, we’ve always been at the top of the fold for all of the keywords. We’ve been very lucky in that sense, and we haven’t had to spend a ton of money on Google search or anything like that. I know AI search is creeping up and we keep a pulse on it, but we haven’t invested in advertising on AI.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

AI has boomed over the last two years, especially in your industry, with people asking where to buy wholesale teddy bears online. How do you think your brand shows up now, and how do you feel about how you look in AI search?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

I’m a big user of AI, but not necessarily for writing or pictures. I know that’s very popular, and when people say they use AI, they assume it’s for one or the other. I use it to make improvements to the website, look at numbers and decide what to buy next year, things no human could do unless I hired someone full time. On one hand AI does a lot of work for you, but because it can do so much, you end up putting more on your plate. It’s a bit of a paradox. It’s like getting a new power tool: you think, wow, I can finally repair that barn. That’s more work, but it’s good, productive work.
So I make sure that when I use AI it’s for productive reasons and that I know what I’m doing. I’m not just blindly saying “do something cool” and watching the results. I want to know exactly what a webhook is and what an API is, because you want to be able to explain to others what it’s doing for you. That’s been a big thing for us.
As for how we show up, we typed in our name anonymously and asked what it thought about Plush in a Rush, and it gave a pretty good, standard answer. I thought, that’s a pretty good assessment of who we are, so they weren’t wrong. We monitor it from time to time to see how it’s evolving, because I might try something one week and it doesn’t have the capability, and when I come back in two or three weeks, sure enough, it can do it. I don’t have to wait long for it to evolve, and we’ll see if it plateaus. It’s like the iPhone. When you got the first one you thought, this is amazing, and the second was a vast improvement, and the third was better, but after that it was marginal improvements. I wonder whether AI will plateau, and I’m sure that will be enough. It’s pretty exciting. I’m trying to stay on top of it and not be one of the anti-AI people, but also not make AI my CEO.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

A hundred percent. Make it your assistant, not something that takes over your life. Your blog celebrates customers, florists, ministries and key clubs, and how your plush ends up comforting kids in hospitals or after disasters. Why lead with other people’s stories, and how does that shape the brand without feeling like marketing?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

There’s a company called StoryBrand, and I forget the name of the guy who does it. I’ve read a few of his books. It always talks about making your customer the main character and yourself the supporting character, the Obi-Wan Kenobi to their Luke Skywalker. So we put the focus on them and what they do. I ask myself how many people are actually going to read a blog post about some floral shop or some charity, and I know they will read it and share it. If anything, they’ll become more loyal.
That’s the way we go about it, rather than focusing on a brand-new bear and all its new features, because teddy bears haven’t really changed all that much since their advent a hundred or so years ago. But our customers do change, and they’re always doing new things with them. That’s why we choose to focus on them and their store and what they’re doing, and not make it about us.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

That’s Donald Miller. I had to look it up too. You’ve told Rainn that systems matter as much as people for a small team competing with much bigger players. What does that look like in practice, and what advice would you give a founder trying to build long-lasting authority in a niche without a big marketing budget?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

That’s the hard part, because I came in when there was a customer base but no one on the net. We were able to build up the net business, and the brick-and-mortar side kept us afloat. I wouldn’t know what to do if you were just starting off and going to sell one product online. That’s not really my forte. I’ve listened to podcasts where they talk about some product that blew up, but if you read between the lines it was their fourth or fifth try. They finally struck gold on the fifth or sixth try because they had all that experience going forward. So I’d advise people just starting up that the one you’re doing right now probably isn’t the one that’s going to put food on the table right away, but you’ve got to start somewhere. As long as you learn something from it and didn’t go bankrupt doing it, it’s money well spent.
As for me, I only have five employees in the back and one in the front who handles customer service. We sometimes bring on a second person during the season, and sometimes they stay on longer. And there’s me, working remotely. Our fixed expenses are all bundled up, so I know exactly what we’re going to spend every month. The only thing that changes is how much we buy, and what we buy is what we want to sell. It’s a matter of making sure your warehouse is full of products people want to buy right away. If you bought something that didn’t go well, you lower the price, move on and learn from it. I don’t want to become the biggest distributor in the country. When vendors much bigger than us come by, they say, wow, this is it? They’re impressed by how we punch above our class.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

That’s amazing. What’s next for you and America’s Plush Headquarters?

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

I just moved out here to Castle Rock. I go into Dallas a few times a month for a few days, and I’m in constant communication with my team there. I have cameras in all the spots, I can get on the intercom and talk, and if the phone rings it rings to my home office. I’m able to get numbers, but I’m trying to maximize what AI can do for me, as a kind of force multiplier. My uncle, my partner, is semi-retired, so I’m asking what he did that I need to learn, which I’m doing, and what is just old school that doesn’t need to be done anymore. And who do I need on premises to be my right-hand man or woman? That’s pretty much what I’m thinking now.
It’s about getting smarter about how we sell and how we position ourselves on the web, and being able to stick and move in the new world of AI, and whatever pandemics or tariffs or strikes may come. We really don’t waver. We just go forward. Even during COVID or the tariffs, we never mentioned the word COVID or tariffs. We just kept on keeping on, and I think people appreciate some level of stability with their vendors.

Podcast interviewer: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

A hundred percent, I would agree. All right, Todd, I really appreciate you coming on the Wytpod and sharing your story and the brand. Thank you so much.

Podcast guest: Wholesale Plush, Customers First & AI as a Power Tool with Todd Steinberg

For sure. Thanks for having me on, Stevie.

Get a Proposal

Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call

    Form data

    Name*

    Email*

    Website*

    Phone*

    Schedule My 30 Minutes Consultation Call


    Ready to think big?

      Form data

      Would you prefer to talk to someone in peron?

      SPEAK WITH A STRATEGIST